What Do Homeowners Regret Most After a Shower Remodel?
The five most common regrets homeowners have after a shower remodel are: (1) choosing the cheapest bid, (2) not understanding what was behind the walls, (3) picking high-maintenance finishes like tile and grout, (4) focusing on the surface instead of the structure, and (5) assuming all contractors build the same way. Every one of these regrets shows up when we tear out failed showers across San Diego County.
By Bill Thompson, Owner, California Bathrooms, Inc.
We see it every week.
A homeowner calls us because their shower — the one they paid someone to remodel a few years ago — is failing. Mold behind the walls. Water damage spreading into the framing. A full tear-out.
Every time, the story is the same. And the regrets are the same.
Regret #1: Choosing the Cheapest Bid
It makes sense at the time. You get three quotes, two are close, one is significantly cheaper. So you go with the low bid. The problem is the cheapest bid usually means something was skipped — and the things that get skipped are always the things you can’t see.
Regret #2: Not Understanding What Was Behind the Walls
Most homeowners have no idea what’s behind their shower walls. They don’t know if there’s waterproofing. They don’t know if the framing is solid. They trusted someone to build it right and never had a reason to question it — until the problems started.
Regret #3: Picking Finishes That Create Maintenance Problems
Tile and grout look great on day one. Fast forward a year or two: grout starts discoloring, soap scum builds up, and cleaning takes longer and longer. That’s why so many people come to us saying “I just want something easier to deal with.”
Regret #4: Focusing on the Surface, Not What’s Behind It
Most homeowners choose based on what they can see: tile vs panels, color, style. But the failures we deal with almost never start on the surface. They start behind it — no waterproofing, poor drainage, movement in the walls, bad sealing around fixtures.
Regret #5: Assuming All Contractors Build the Same Way
On the surface, a lot of proposals look similar. But how the shower is actually built can be completely different. Some build to minimum code, some skip steps you’ll never see, some rely on caulk and grout to do jobs they were never meant to do. Unless you know what to look for, it’s hard to tell the difference upfront.
How Do You Avoid These Regrets?
Every one of these regrets has the same fix: do it once, do it right, don’t look at it again.
That means building around what still works 10–20 years from now — not what looks good on day one. Waterproofing first. Drainage engineered correctly. Structure that doesn’t move. Finishes that don’t create maintenance problems.
Frequently asked questions
Choosing a contractor based on price alone. The cheapest bid often means corners are cut behind the walls. These shortcuts typically lead to water damage and full tear-outs within 5–10 years.
No. Tile is a surface finish, not a waterproofing material. Water penetrates through grout over time. A dedicated waterproof membrane behind the tile is required.
Ask about waterproofing: what system they install behind the tile or panels. Ask if they tear down to the studs. Ask about warranties — both labor and manufacturer. A contractor who builds properly will explain their process clearly.
Focus on what’s behind the walls, not just the surface. Ensure your contractor installs proper waterproofing, correct drainage, and addresses ventilation. Look for manufacturer warranties on materials, not just labor guarantees.
Trusted Credentials
Our Project Gallery
Real San Diego Homeowners. Real Results. Real Reviews.
California Bathrooms has completed hundreds of bathroom remodels across San Diego County. Every review below comes directly from Google, unfiltered and unedited. See why homeowners from Chula Vista to Carlsbad trust us with their most important rooms.
“Johnathan Hatch came out for my free estimate. Johnathan was a very helpful pleasant knowledgeable guy who was a pleasure to meet. Great ability to relate yet stayed focused on what is needed.”
Kevin O'Donnell
“Aldo and Jesse did a PHENOMENAL job with our bathroom! They were prompt, efficient, kind, and polite. Left no mess and took such good care of our bathroom. It was an absolute pleasure getting to work with them and I’d recommend them for any job!”
Emilia Drago
“My wife and I got one of our bathrooms done a couple weeks ago and are extremely pleased with the result. Johnathan came out and helped through the entire process and was extremely helpful and thorough. He answered every question we had. If you’re considering a bathroom remodel look no further. Professional company, ask for Johnathan and he will get you all set up.”
Gage
“I recently had my bathroom remodeled by California Bathrooms, and I’m extremely happy with how everything turned out. Johnathan, their design consultant, guided me through the entire process and made it seamless from start to finish with his clear communication and support. I’m genuinely grateful for him and the dedication he brings to his work. I highly recommend California Bathrooms and Johnathan to anyone considering a remodel—absolutely worth the investment.”
Alessandro
“Really impressed with how professional and helpful this experience has been from start to finish. Johnny came out to get me my estimate and they ended up being the most competitive company from price and quality out of 4 quotes I received. I decided to give them a try and couldn’t be happier. My remodel turned out better than I expected and I couldn’t recommend this company enough. I’d leave 6 stars if I could.”
Broc
“We recently had our parents’ bathroom remodeled, and we’re very pleased with the results. The team added a secure bench & handlebars in the shower and made the entire space safer and more user-friendly for my elderly parents. Aldo was professional, knowledgeable, and attentive to every detail. The bathroom is exactly what we hoped for, and we highly recommend California Bathrooms for their quality and care.”
Jendark R
“California Bathrooms was the BEST! My wife and I shopped several other companies before choosing them and we’re so happy we did. They understood our vision and delivered on budget and on time. I would highly recommend.”
Chris Vertrees
Contact Us
Mon-Fri: 8am - 6pm
Sat: 9am - 2pm
Sun: Closed